Randwick and Coogee sit at a unique intersection of Sydney's Jewish life across every life stage. Emanuel School at 20 Stanley Street, Randwick — co-educational, pluralist, Pre-K to Year 12, around 920 students — is one of Australia's largest Jewish day schools. Coogee Synagogue (Coogee War Memorial Or Hadash) at 121 Brook Street, founded in 1960 by Holocaust survivors and now a community of more than 300 led by Rabbi Elozer Gestetner, carries a heritage unlike any other Sydney shule. The University of New South Wales at adjacent Kensington brings a substantial Jewish student community (AUJS UNSW, Hillel Jewish Student Services), and Sir Moses Montefiore Home Randwick is one of the major Jewish aged care facilities in Sydney. A family law matter here could involve almost any life stage — young university couples, established Emanuel School families, mature couples with adult children, or elderly residents addressing estate planning and end-of-life arrangements. I'm Elisa Rothschild, principal at Fogarty Oliver Rothschild — a Melbourne-based family lawyer with 14 years in practice and a Jewish family law specialty, serving Randwick and Coogee clients by Zoom, phone and in-person Sydney visits.
Who I help in Randwick and Coogee
Emanuel School families — pluralist Jewish families with children from Pre-K to Year 12, the school's broad orientation spanning Progressive, Conservative, Orthodox and culturally Jewish families, often within the same parent body — whose separations involve standard Eastern Suburbs property and parenting matters with school continuity a recurring central concern. Coogee Synagogue community members, many with multi-generational connections and Holocaust-survivor family heritage, in a closely connected community where matters are typically handled with substantial care for community continuity.
Holocaust survivor families and second-generation matters, where estate planning and major life transitions benefit from a lawyer who understands the cultural and historical context — not as a legal category, but out of respect for the specific family histories involved. Younger Jewish residents and UNSW-adjacent professionals — students and recent graduates staying in the area, with matters around first marriages, first homes, first children — some from Sydney's other Jewish communities, some relocated from Melbourne or interstate, some international students or recent migrants.
Mature Randwick and Coogee families with substantial long-held homes and often adult or near-adult children; estate planning for the senior generation, including residents at Sir Moses Montefiore Home or their adult children arranging matters on their behalf, needing wills, advance care directives and powers of attorney that respect halachic considerations; and non-Jewish residents, who make up about half the practice's general family law work.
Family law for Emanuel School families
Emanuel is a pluralist Jewish school — welcoming families across the observance spectrum and educating Progressive, Conservative, Orthodox and culturally Jewish children together — which has practical implications for separating couples whose children attend. School continuity is usually a priority: most parents want children to continue through to Year 12 regardless of the separation, so parenting orders typically address fee responsibility (typically $25,000–$40,000 per child per year depending on year level), school commute logistics from both households, and school-event attendance.
Community navigation matters because Emanuel families know each other through the school, so a separation is visible within the parent community to some degree — how visible depends on careful drafting of any court documents, settlement by consent where possible, and considered lawyer selection. The school's pluralist orientation means parenting orders sometimes need to specify which religious framework the children identify with, particularly where parents are at different points on the spectrum or one parent intends to disengage from Jewish education while the other wants continued involvement.
Many Emanuel students participate in youth movements, and parenting orders sometimes address how these involvements continue across two households. The broader Progressive/pluralist Jewish family law context is covered in more depth on the Woollahra page (linked from the Sydney hub).
Jewish family law — civil divorce, the Sydney Beth Din, the get
A civil divorce ends your marriage under Australian law. A get ends it under Jewish law. They are separate processes with separate requirements, and most clients need both — particularly the wife, for whom the absence of a get has serious consequences for any future Orthodox remarriage and for the halachic status of any future children.
The Sydney Beth Din is at 25 O'Brien Street, Bondi Beach — about 15 minutes from Randwick by car — with senior Dayanim Rabbi Moshe Gutnick and Rabbi Yehoram Ulman handling the religious side of divorce. For Randwick and Coogee clients the get question often varies by which framework the marriage was conducted under: for Orthodox-ceremony marriages (common among Coogee Synagogue families and some Emanuel-affiliated families) the get matters and the Beth Din process applies; for Progressive-ceremony marriages (common among many Emanuel families) the question may be different and is addressed individually; and for interfaith or non-religious marriages the religious-dissolution question doesn't arise in the same way.
I work with the Sydney Beth Din directly for client matters and tailor the approach to each client's specific religious framework.
Property settlement in Randwick and Coogee
Settlements here vary substantially by circumstances. Real estate ranges from established Federation and Victorian-era homes in the inner streets to more contemporary apartments and townhouses near UNSW and the beach — substantial Randwick homes can sit in the $3–5 million range while smaller Coogee apartments are more modest — so valuation needs appropriate expertise. Beachside Coogee properties with ocean views or beach proximity command premiums, with coastal exposure, body corporate considerations and insurance positions all factoring into the analysis.
Some Coogee families have multi-generational property arrangements going back to the 1950s and 1960s — homes purchased by Holocaust-survivor parents or grandparents now held by the next generation — which require careful attention to the history of ownership and existing documentation. Family trusts and business interests are handled in the standard way, superannuation (often the second-largest asset) is split under Part VIIIB, investment property portfolios are common, and Israeli or overseas property is handled through the firm's Israeli professional contacts.
Emanuel School fees (typically $25,000–$40,000 per child per year) and their future responsibility are addressed in orders. For matters involving clients whose parents are in care at Sir Moses Montefiore Home, the broader estate context often features alongside the immediate separation, so coordinated handling matters. The court applies the four-step process: identify the asset pool, assess contributions, assess future needs, determine what is just and equitable.
Parenting matters across family configurations
The 2024 reforms repealed the presumption of equal shared parental responsibility; the test now focuses on the best interests of each child, with safety as paramount. Religious upbringing across the observance spectrum is a recurring issue — Emanuel families in particular often have parents at different observance levels — so orders address decisions about Jewish education, shule attendance, bar/bat mitzvah preparation, and which religious framework the children identify with. Schooling decisions (whether children continue at Emanuel, transfer to another Jewish day school or move to a state school, future fee responsibility, and coordination of school-related parent involvement) feature heavily.
The Yomim Tovim each have specific timing built into parenting plans, and for observant families Shabbos arrangements (handovers around sunset, no phone contact during Shabbos) are built into orders. Many Coogee Synagogue families have grandparents heavily involved in family life, so plans sometimes address grandparent contact, particularly where grandparents have been substantial caregivers.
The community is generally inclusive, so parenting matters for LGBTQ+ Jewish families involve all the standard considerations. University-age children are a specific issue for some Randwick families — while parenting orders generally don't apply once children turn 18, the family dynamics around UNSW-age children can be part of the practical context. I draft parenting plans and consent orders that address these issues explicitly.
Halachic prenups and estate planning for the senior generation
The halachic prenup conversation needs different approaches for different couples — particularly relevant here given the range of observance levels. For Orthodox-affiliated couples a halachic prenup + Binding Financial Agreement is the standard approach; for Progressive or Conservative couples a BFA on its own may be sufficient; for Sephardi couples additional cultural-specific considerations apply. The starting point is understanding what each couple wants the document to do and what type is right for their circumstances.
For clients with parents or grandparents at Sir Moses Montefiore Home, or approaching the later stages of life themselves, estate planning is often as important as any active family law matter. The work includes Jewish wills that respect halachic inheritance principles while withstanding Succession Act 2006 (NSW) Family Provision scrutiny (halachic wills for Orthodox-affiliated families like many at Coogee Synagogue, standard Australian wills where appropriate for Progressive families), powers of attorney and advance care directives that can include religious provisions (kashrus, Shabbos observance, end-of-life care preferences), estate administration sensitive to Jewish customs (burial typically within 24–48 hours under halacha, shiva observance), inter-generational planning through trusts, inter vivos transfers and beneficiary arrangements, and Israel-Australia inheritance matters handled through the firm's Israeli contacts.
On logistics: the initial consultation is free, 45 minutes, by Zoom or phone in nearly all cases. I travel to Sydney regularly, and for clients with limited mobility (including residents of care facilities) in-person attendance can be arranged at the client's location, with no additional charge for Sydney travel. Family law is federal — I am admitted in Victoria and to the High Court of Australia and act in Family Court matters Australia-wide, appearing at the Sydney registry in person or by video link. I coordinate get applications directly with the Sydney Beth Din at 25 O'Brien Street, document witnessing happens locally or through me on a visit, and ongoing communication is by email, phone and Zoom.
Jewish family law
Specialist Jewish family law service for Randwick & Coogee
Elisa Rothschild runs a dedicated Jewish family law practice covering civil divorce coordinated with the get, halachic prenuptial agreements, and Jewish wills and estates. The Melbourne Beth Din, the local Orthodox community and the major Jewish day schools are all part of the practical context she works in every day.
Read more about Jewish family law →Frequently asked questions — family law in Randwick & Coogee
My kids are at Emanuel and we're separating. How do we handle the school dimension?+
Most Emanuel parents want children to continue at the school through to Year 12 regardless of the separation. Parenting orders typically address school fee responsibility, school commute logistics from both households, parent-teacher event attendance, and school camp arrangements. The school itself is generally supportive of separated families and works constructively with parents on logistics.
My family has been at Coogee Synagogue for three generations. Will my matter become community knowledge?+
The Coogee Synagogue community is close-knit, so how the matter is conducted affects what becomes visible. Resolving matters by consent rather than contested litigation, careful drafting of any court documents, and considered choices about how the religious side is handled all support discretion. Choosing a Melbourne-based lawyer adds professional distance from the local community.
My parents are at Sir Moses Montefiore Home Randwick and I need to update their estate planning. Can you help?+
Yes. Jewish wills for elderly clients, powers of attorney, advance care directives and broader estate planning are core practice work. For clients with limited mobility, in-person attendance can be arranged at the care facility.
I was at UNSW and recently got married. My partner and I want a prenup. What does that involve?+
For young couples about to marry, a halachic prenup + Binding Financial Agreement is often the right document, providing protection on both the religious and the civil side. Both parties obtain independent legal advice and the process typically takes a few weeks. The right document type depends on the religious framework of your wedding ceremony, which we discuss at the consultation.
We're an observant Coogee family and my partner is from a Progressive background. How does that work?+
This is one of the more common Randwick/Coogee situations. Mixed-observance couples need parenting orders that address religious-upbringing decisions explicitly, BFAs that work for both spouses' religious frameworks, and Beth Din coordination that respects both parties' positions. The work is tailored to your specific circumstances.
Will my matter be heard in Sydney?+
Yes — for Sydney-resident clients, the matter is heard at the Sydney registry of the Federal Circuit and Family Court. I appear there in person or by video link where the court permits.
My partner is refusing to give me the get. What can I do?+
There are options — civil law mechanisms, Sydney Beth Din pressure, community advocacy, and specific provisions that can sometimes be drafted into property orders. The right strategy depends on the specifics, and a confidential conversation is the starting point.
My parents are Holocaust survivors and I want to preserve family history through estate planning. Can you help?+
Yes. Estate planning for survivor families often involves substantial care to preserve family history, traditions and the values that shaped the family. It isn't a separate legal category — it's careful, respectful estate planning that takes the full family context into account.
Reviewed by Elisa Rothschild BA/LLB — Principal Lawyer, Fogarty Oliver Rothschild. Last reviewed 2026-05-22.